A group member for Lido has accused Competitor Rocket Pool claimed in a July 4 social media publish that it was too centralized. Each Lido and Rocket Pool are liquid stake protocols that permit customers to delegate their cryptocurrency to validators and obtain by-product tokens in change.
In accordance with Dmitry Gusakov, Lido Group Stake Lead, Rocket Pool contracts are managed by the Rocket Pool group, so the group can change any parameters and invoke any methodology. Which means Rocket Pool builders can enhance the inflation fee to any excessive share or enhance the charges as much as 100%.
Gusakov claimed that this vulnerability doesn't exist in Lido's contracts as a result of these actions in Lido are "fully managed by [decentralized autonomous organization] LidoDAO.”
Waq, a member of the Rocket Pool Grants Administration Committee, responded to the allegation, stating that the vulnerability is already recognized to the group and might be mounted sooner or later. Waq accused the Lido group of embracing the invention of an already recognized subject.
Right here we go once more with the "model new" discoveries of @Rocket_Pool Tremendous vicious as soon as once more. Not a single phrase on how the group has been working to repair the difficulty for over a yr and what progress we're making. As all the time, as soon as we repair the issue, they're going to rush to gather the credit score.
— The opposite | Rocket Gas (@waqqaqattack) July 4, 2023
In accordance with Gusakov's publish, the RocketStorage contract on the Ethereum handle 0x1d8f8f00cfa6758d7bE78336684788Fb0ee0Fa46 accommodates a parameter known as "Guardian". Many options in Rocket Pool contracts are additionally marked as "onlyGuardian", that means they'll solely be accessed by the account listed on this parameter, which is presently set to the RocketPool deployer account at 0x0cCF14983364A7735d369879603930Afe10df21e.
Actions that the “Guardian” can carry out embrace altering the “RPL InflationIntervalRate” and the “ETH DepositFee”, which suggests the group will enhance the inflation fee of the Rocket Pool Governance Token (RPL) or person deposits by You may set the take away price to 100%, Gusakov defined.
Content material Creator Chris Blec shared the publish: assert that it proves that "pDAO will not be a DAO" or that RPL token holders aren't really answerable for Rocket Pool's governance.
In response, RocketPool group advocate Jasper.lens responded specified that the group is already conscious of this centralization subject, which might be mounted within the upcoming Saturn improve. In accordance with Jasper, the centralization got here at a time when voting programs for Rocket Pool's DAO have been nonetheless being developed and examined. The group determined to not permit the DAO to observe on-chain voting in the course of the first take a look at part. Nevertheless, testing is now full and the forthcoming Saturn improve "is all about closing the decentralization gaps."
In a remark agreeing with Jasper.lens' contribution, Waq claims that the Rocket Pool group "has been working to repair this subject for over a yr" and predicted that after the difficulty is mounted, the Lido group would "pounce on recognition, as all the time."
Liquid staking protocols have been rising in recognition over the previous few months. On Might 1, blockchain analytics platform DefiLlama acknowledged that these protocols have overtaken decentralized exchanges as the highest DeFi class when it comes to whole locked worth. On Might 30, Tenet partnered with LayerZero to implement liquid staking on extra blockchains sooner or later.
